Can You Substitute Synthetic Fibers for Wire Mesh?
The use of welded wire mesh in residential slabs has been on the decline for the last ten years as more contractors switch to synthetic-fiber-reinforced concrete. Synthetic fibers — which are often called Fibermesh, a well-known brand — have been marketed as a substitute for wire mesh in residential slabs.
Most contractors are eager to avoid the hassle of wrestling with wire mesh, and prefer the easier option of ordering synthetic fibers from their ready-mix supplier. Jon Hanson is the vice president and estimator at Walker Construction, a concrete contractor in Stowe, Vt. "We used to buy bundles and bundles of rolls of wire mesh, but we don't do that anymore," says Hanson. "Now we use Fibermesh in just about all our slabs, unless it is a structural slab with a rebar mat."Most contractors are eager to avoid the hassle of wrestling with wire mesh, and prefer the easier option of ordering synthetic fibers from their ready-mix supplier. Jon Hanson is the vice president and estimator at Walker Construction, a concrete contractor in Stowe, Vt. "We used to buy bundles and bundles of rolls of wire mesh, but we don't do that anymore," says Hanson. "Now we use Fibermesh in just about all our slabs, unless it is a structural slab with a rebar mat."Although often seen as a substitute for wire mesh, synthetic fibers, at least at manufacturers' recommended dosages, don't perform the same function. Properly placed wire mesh helps hold together a hardened slab, even if the soil settles slightly. Unlike most synthetic fibers, wire mesh also controls drying shrinkage cracking — the type of cracking which can occur during a period of several weeks after the pour.At typical dosages, the benefits of synthetic fibers occur only during the first few hours after the concrete is placed; after that time, they provide no real benefits. Many studies have verified that synthetic fibers, unlike wire mesh, reduce plastic shrinkage cracking. Plastic shrinkage cracking occurs as the concrete makes the transition from liquid to a hardened slab. "Synthetic fibers help with avoiding plastic shrinkage cracks, but they don't do much after the concrete hardens, in terms of providing a lot of strength for the slab later on," admits Hal Payne, marketing services manager at Synthetic Industries, the manufacturer of Fibermesh.
Plastic shrinkage cracking occurs only in weather conditions that encourage
premature drying of the concrete surface. Although it is definitely a concern
on a hot, dry, windy day, there is probably no danger of plastic shrinkage cracking
when concrete is poured in cool, cloudy, windless conditions.
The reason that synthetic fibers have been successfully marketed as a substitute
for wire mesh is that most nonstructural residential concrete slabs don't need
much reinforcement. Barring unusual soil conditions, if a residential slab is
being placed on a well-compacted subbase, wire mesh — or, for that matter,
synthetic fibers — can be safely omitted. Depending on whether you want
to control either plastic shrinkage cracking or drying shrinkage cracking, either
synthetic fibers or wire mesh may be used. And if a residential slab actually
needs reinforcement — either because it is partially unsupported or because
it is load-bearing — then what you need is rebar, not wire mesh or synthetic
fibers.
Hairy slabs? Some concrete contractors worry
that fiber-reinforced concrete will produce a difficult-to-finish, hairy slab.
"When synthetic fibers first came on to the market, we had these real long,
real thick fibers," says Payne. "Finishers didn't like them, because it was
hard to get the fibers mixed in and the concrete was hard to finish. Since then
the whole industry has changed. We now use a mix of fiber lengths and diameters,
and the product gets mixed in easier."
Hanson, who has installed a lot of fiber-reinforced concrete, hasn't had any
finishing problems. "The power trowels go right over it, and lay the fibers
down," says Hanson. "Many of the fibers will pop up later, but ultraviolet light
burns them off, as long as they are exposed to daylight. After a year you don't
see them anymore."
Fiber Options
Polypropylene is the most commonly used synthetic fiber, but other types of
fiber, including nylon and polyolefin, are also available. Polypropylene fibers
come in two different formats: fibrillated and monofilament. Fibrillated fibers
have been deformed and shredded to form a net-like mesh that engages more tightly
with cement paste than monofilament fibers. The main disadvantage with fibrillated
fibers is their tendency to protrude from a slab.
Contractors who don't want to wait for protruding fibers to wear off can burn
them off with a torch, or specify monofilament polypropylene. Although monofilament
fibers are less tenacious, they are less likely to stick up than fibrillated
polypropylene. Another alternative is to specify nylon fibers, which also lay
down better than fibrillated polypropylene.
Permeability. Although some synthetic fiber
manufacturers have claimed that fibers make concrete less permeable, there is
no evidence that this is true, at least at common dosage levels. "A few years
ago, we claimed, along with other companies, that the use of synthetic fibers
reduced the permeability of concrete," says Fibermesh's Payne. "We have changed
that claim. Fibers really don't affect permeability."
Neal Berke, principal scientist at Grace Construction Products, a manufacturer
of polypropylene fibers, agrees. "In good quality concrete, fibers have no effect
on permeability," he says. "To reduce the permeability, you'd be better off
adding a water reducer and lowering the water-to-cement ratio."
What's the best dosage? The recommended dosages
provided by synthetic fiber manufacturers are not necessarily the optimal dosages
for fiber concrete. Most ready-mix suppliers charge an extra $7 or $8 per cubic
yard to add 1 1/2 pounds of polypropylene fibers to their concrete, amounting
to an upcharge of about 10%. This dosage level has been chosen by the fiber
manufacturers to make synthetic fiber's price competitive with wire mesh.
"Fiber concrete is a wonderful technology with many good uses, at the right
dosage," says Parviz Soroushian, professor of civil and environmental engineering
at Michigan State University. "But the manufacturers' recommended dosages are
not really sufficient to improve the hardened concrete properties. At 0.1% by
volume, which is equivalent to the typical manufacturers' recommendations of
1 1/2 pounds per cubic yard, the benefits are marginal in hardened concrete.
You need about 3 pounds of fiber per cubic yard. Once you double the dosage,
you have much to gain — improvements in impact resistance, toughness, and
control of drying shrinkage cracking."
Bob Cruso, president of Nycon, a manufacturer of synthetic fibers, doesn't dispute
Soroushian's points. "We would love to be able to promote higher dosage levels,
and we do for some applications," says Cruso. "But we have to look at what we
can offer at a price that is somewhat equal to welded wire mesh, because that's
what we are competing against. That's unfortunate, but that's the way it is."
Contractors interested in achieving the best possible performance from synthetic
fibers should consider the option of doubling the normal fiber dosage recommended
by the fiber manufacturers. Before adjusting the dosage, though, be sure to
consult with your ready-mix supplier and the fiber manufacturer's technical
experts, since higher fiber dosages may require less aggregate and more cement
paste in the concrete mix.
Fiber Manufacturers
In addition to Fibermesh (Synthetic Industries; 800/635-2308; www.fiber-mesh.com),
several other manufacturers make polypropylene fibers, including Columbian Fibersource
(800/821-4391; www.fibersource.org),
Forta (800/245-0306; www.fortacorp.com),
and Grace Construction Products (877/423-6491; www.graceconstruction.com).
Nylon fibers are available from Forta and Nycon (800/456-9266; www.nycon.com),
while polyolefin fibers are available from 3M (888/364-3577; www.3M.com/corrosion).
Connect with customers looking to do your most profitable projects in the areas you like to work.
Type of Pro*
This article has been provided by www.jlconline.com . JLC-Online is produced by the editors and publishers of The Journal of Light Construction, a monthly magazine serving residential and light-commercial builders, remodelers, designers, and other trade professionals.
Heavy-duty macro-synthetic fibers represent the next generation of synthetic technology, capable of a much more higher replacement level than conventional steel reinforcement. The FORTA-FERRO® macro fiber maximizes each of the critical fiber characteristics that contribute to long term durability and crack-control performance. Using advanced co-polymer chemistry and a blend of fiber shapes, along with twisted bundles and special gray color to assure uniform mixing and excellent surface finish, this unique best-of-its-kind macrosynthetic may be used at a much higher dosage (3.0,5.0,7.5 lbs./cu.yd. or more). FORTA-FERRO® has the highest slab curling reduction and best post-crack performance values of any synthetic fiber in its class.